Mods at /r/skincareaddiction caught in proven collusion with companies, accepting payment for promoting submissions and products.
565 2015-03-31 by tdsfp
I haven't seen this anywhere else on reddit, but 3 mods from /r/skincareaddiction were recently banned because they were charging upwards of $1,100 per month to promote products, routines and companies.
You can read about it on the front page of that subreddit, it's all anyone is talking about right now.
There is also hard evidence in the form of basically a press sheet for the service http://i.imgur.com/l8YTxVh.png
It's not often we get a proven case like this, and also it's interesting that SCA is a relatively small and niche community.
This instance makes it easy to see how a few rogue mods can easily take matters into their own hands and profit from status and discredit the reputation of a subreddit.
That being said, I'm not trying use this as proof of anything else or any other moderator problems. It just feels indicative of a lot of discussion that's been going on here recently.
41 comments
30 joe-6pak 2015-03-31
Whenever you are looking at media
and you cannot identify the product being sold
you are that product.
0 kizzzzurt 2015-03-31
That is more a quote about data collection in a modern era and selling said PII, but I guess it could stretch to here.
-1 joe-6pak 2015-03-31
What is the business model here?
It isn't advertising.
5 kizzzzurt 2015-03-31
? How is it not advertising if they are accepting payment for promotion for selling a product..?
What isn't advertising?
-1 NHMatt 2015-03-31
Edgy to the xtreme.
22 un1ty 2015-03-31
McReddit is rotten to the core...
7 JamesColesPardon 2015-03-31
I love this term for what reddit has become. Is it yours? May I use it?
5 Niteowlthethird 2015-03-31
For a small subscription cost
2 un1ty 2015-03-31
Its free to use :)
But it wasn't mine - I remember seeing it and expressing the same.
2 JamesColesPardon 2015-03-31
Its great.
19 [deleted] 2015-03-31
Hey guys, do this: PM a mod and offer money to promote something... anything. Watch how fast they reply.
7 SeaRavenTX 2015-03-31
I don't have money but I can offer them this
3 thesepigswillplay 2015-03-31
You have yourself a deal.
13 know_comment 2015-03-31
I figured that's what happened. It's been pretty well known for a while that the mods over there were involved in affiliate marketing.
7 [deleted] 2015-03-31
[deleted]
2 deebballer 2015-03-31
All those trillionaires out there
6 m0q 2015-03-31
looks like that mod got wild and made the money on the side instead of how getting through reddit admins.
now is out and maybe it will start talking
5 pizzahedron 2015-03-31
it is also important to note that at least one mod was banned for involvement in the scam, when she was not actually involved. she may have been an unliked mod for other, sufficient reasons, but it's important to not throw out the half-burned rubber ducky with the bathwater. they go into different trashcans. that user's account has been unbanned, but she is no longer a mod.
http://np.reddit.com/r/SkincareAddiction/comments/30xtsm/iswearimagirl_unbanned/cpwsamy
1 AutoModerator 2015-03-31
While not required, you are requested to use the NP domain of reddit when crossposting. This helps to protect both your account, and the accounts of other users, from administrative shadowbans. The NP domain can be accessed by prefacing your reddit link with np.reddit.com.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5 pizzahedron 2015-03-31
thanks bot! edited.
5 FlinchSham 2015-03-31
This is the kind of conspiracy that I like. Not any of that "hurr durr the Holocaust never happened" bullshit.
3 ronintetsuro 2015-03-31
Totally unnecessary propaganda catapult detected.
3 FlinchSham 2015-03-31
Gosh darnit. My zionist catapult would have worked if it weren't for you meddling kids!
3 ronintetsuro 2015-03-31
This conversation had nothing to do with the Holocaust. And you felt you needed to change that.
2 FlinchSham 2015-03-31
Yes.
4 Xtorting 2015-03-31
Makes you wonder what else is going on out there. One reason my ban hammer is so light on /r/ProjectAra is to avoid showing favorites like we see here. Want to talk about another modular device that doesn't run Android or ARA modules? No problem, as long as it's a modular device.
2 emilskoda 2015-03-31
I'm not saying it's wrong and I enjoy the sub, but I think I remember reading that the mods of r/circlejerk have an affiliate youtube site they make money off of. I guess what I'm trying to say is there's a line and SCA mods crossed it.
6 [deleted] 2015-03-31
[deleted]
2 emilskoda 2015-03-31
Yes if you're trying to underhandedly steer people towards paying for a product or service for personal profit. No if you're openly collecting money from ad revenue on Youtube.
6 exwasstalking 2015-03-31
I think the point is that it is highly unlikely that it is just skin care and circle jerking that are being exploited. I'm sure similar schemes are going on on the larger, more visible forums.
5 emilskoda 2015-03-31
I totally agree with you. /r/HailCorporate really tries to toe the line, even if I think they might get carried away, sometimes.
But really, the worst that can happen is that this safe-haven turns into facebook. Then we just migrate to reddit's next incarnation.
Edit: I thought about it some more. The worst that can happen is that reddit turns into facebook without anyone realizing it. Then we're all fucked.
7 exwasstalking 2015-03-31
It kind of feels like we are headed that way. The idea of taking money to stifle topics and promote others is also part of this. If skincare mods can be swayed, what's to say r/worldnews can't? I mean, it makes sense with how quick they are to delete certain topics. It's not the end of the world but it is shady and frustrating. Some people come here to get news that isn't cherry picked by the same media outlets, it would be a shame if that is still going on by the same players behind the scenes.
4 emilskoda 2015-03-31
I would be surprised if that wasn't going on, at least to some extent, already. We know the way media works, regardless of it's sovereign political power. It's only a matter of time before any entity becomes controlled by it's influence.
2 Xtorting 2015-03-31
Google help us.
2 Philly267 2015-03-31
What's the next reddit?
1 emilskoda 2015-03-31
If it already exists I'm unaware of it. It reminds me of the Myspace days when Facebook came around, or even the Digg story. When it happens it will be a natural transition.
-8 Paulpaps 2015-03-31
My god something that is an actual conspiracy! Nice, makes a change from all the jew bashing that goes on here.
-2 [deleted] 2015-03-31
[deleted]
-9 Paulpaps 2015-03-31
Oh fuck off with the sense of superiority. Go and live in your fantasy world.
-10 [deleted] 2015-03-31
[deleted]
3 SaxonWitch 2015-03-31
I disagree as it would set a dangerous precedence for advertisers swamping every conceivable sub and make them unreadable.
2 beanx 2015-03-31
pretty sure that violates reddit's TOS. bigtime.