Anyone else notice Google's suggested searches being related to what they were just discussing out loud?
61 2016-07-16 by sleepcake
I've noticed that when making searches, particularly on YouTube and Google, the suggested searches are sometimes eerily similar to what I had just been talking about. Things that I don't think I've ever searched for on my phone/other device.
My best example was when my brothers and I saw an artist perform a cover of "Rocket Man" at a concert. On the car ride home, we were disputing the lyrics to the song. We finally decided to google the lyrics and after I typed "roc" the suggested search said "Rocket man lyrics".
I don't think this was a coincidence. I don't think most people who start a search with "roc" are looking for the lyrics to Rocket Man.
I'm pretty much convinced that my phone is listening to my conversations and using the data to "personalize" my phone experience.
Does anyone else have any similar experiences? Unfortunately, I'm not entirely sure how to protect myself from it.
34 comments
16 bitcoin_noob 2016-07-16
No, but of the people who were at the concert with you, a lot of them would have googled the same thing.
Everyones locations are being tracked, thats no secret. Your search suggestion was based on your location and what others there were searching.
7 lonedog 2016-07-16
this is the real answer. Your phone knew you were at a concert, knew others at the concert, saw they too were searching for rocketman lyrics, figured "hey, this guy was at the same concert with all these other people who are looking for rocketman lyrics, he's probably gonna be looking for the same thing" but in binary.
This is still fucking scary when you think about it.
2 Dick_Johnson1 2016-07-16
turn your location device off on your phone.
8 bradasaurusrex1103 2016-07-16
Yes. And it's even happened to the extent that I've mentioned (and not searched recently) something at dinner table and then boom. Pandora ad that relates... It's fucked. Creepy.
As someone that works in online ads I feel like it's only a matter of time until I turn over a stone that shows me, yes, it has in fact been happening.
2 deaddrop23 2016-07-16
i had a short discussion about kale one night at the dinner table. not 10 minutes later on twitter, i have an ad promoted on my timeline about kale.
2 Bathroomdestroyer 2016-07-16
I made some lemonade once and got for an ad for it later that day. My GF bought some new converse(at a store) and was talking to me about them and I got converse ads. I don't shop for either of these items online and yet Google thinks I need these ads.
7 Autocoprophage 2016-07-16
It's definitely happening, I've tested it. I have a smartphone that I literally only associated with an account for this specific purpose and I tested it by only speaking about very obscure and idiosyncratic products in the presence of the phone. It's happening.
5 dejeneration 2016-07-16
Are you using Android? Make sure you disable OK Google, probably a lot of other things to disable, but that's a biggie.
Also, if your privacy settings aren't locked down in Gmail/Google search (and your mic is on and you allow your phone or browser to use the mic), this page might be a little scary.
1 sleepcake 2016-07-16
I'm using an iPhone. I think I'm going to turn off Siri and make sure Google/YouTube no longer have mic access. Who knows if that'll be enough though.
And thanks for the link, about to read it now.
2 dejeneration 2016-07-16
It's just a link to Google Voice Search history - people were finding that they didn't realize that stuff was stored. You can delete it and block it - but a real issue if you don't even know it exists!
5 imautoparts 2016-07-16
How's this for an eerie 'coincidence'.
Facebook suggested my pot dealer as a potential friend. Nothing - neither of our phones, never an email, NOTHING linked the two of us.
Still a haunting moment all these years later.
1 CelineHagbard 2016-07-16
Maybe more than you'd like to say on an open internet forum, but how did you meet up with him without phones?
2 imautoparts 2016-07-16
She uses constant 'burn phones' (throwaways), and all I had at the time was an old-school land line.
1 CelineHagbard 2016-07-16
Ah, makes sense!
4 [deleted] 2016-07-16
[deleted]
2 MKULTRAserialkillers 2016-07-16
All the time. it's become a running joke.
2 hordak666 2016-07-16
I have noticed it.
2 InspectorBloor 2016-07-16
I Finally noticed this recently. I had my phone out and was listening to some talk putin was giving.
When I pick up my phone and start doing something the first ad I saw anywhere was for "Russian Brides"
Laughed/Got creeped out hard
2 kingcubfan 2016-07-16
For me, its actually what I was thinking. Trips me the f out.
1 Golisten2LennyWhite 2016-07-16
You aren't crazy, me too
2 tacostep 2016-07-16
its happened quite a few times more than i care to admit however could just be coincidence; but then again look where i am
2 slackshack 2016-07-16
I ran into a guy at the hospital his week, hadn't seem each other in over twenty years, had a quick chat and went home. When i got home guess who the first person in the fb suggested people I might know list was? I don't have the fb application and use incognito mode when I use fb .so weird
1 StopNoAndDont 2016-07-16
Why the hell are you even using Alphabet Corp. products? Even Bing's search is safer.
1 rufusjonz 2016-07-16
had you searched for Elton John before or rock music lyrics?
1 pop_n_phresh 2016-07-16
I tried to search Clinton deleted emails and it stopped the auto complete after I got to the "T"
1 NZ_NZ 2016-07-16
everyone wrapped in their own head through the illusion everyone agrees with them. that we are being confirmed.
this is why discussions in open forums are important. yet again they are able to pay a lot of smooth shills too.
1 MoarWottz 2016-07-16
Yup. All the fucking time.
1 Provoken420 2016-07-16
My dad worked at Chevron gas station, every night he clocked off he had to type in this security code for his work for big bills. He went to text his coworker the security code for the safe and it was one of the first suggested words that popped up, it had a bunch of random letters and number. He was using Google Keyboard, never once typed the security code into his phone. He barely uses his phone other than call or text people. I find that quite odd.
1 clinano 2016-07-16
Yep. I was discussing how one now needs to get a boat licence in Norway to drive even small boats. I open fb in chrome and the first ad was boat licencing courses. Now the interesting part is that my phone was switched on, but not logged in. It had restarted itself and I just had it in my pocket with the password log in page open. I hadnt even put the password in when these conversations were being held.
edit. may I add that I am not into boats. it was a random conversation. I have never typed anything into my google search engine about anything connected to boats.
1 YouSeaBlue 2016-07-16
Yes, I have. I can't remember the exact ad, but I know it showed up on my FB feed minutes after he and I mentioned it.
It went something like this: Me; I wonder where you could buy (whatever the item was) Him: I don't know. Not sure where to look.
We probably said a couple more sentences about it. I wanna say it was some kind of craft supply. I opened up my phone, clicked chrome because I don't have the FB app, and the ad for the thing was right there.
It really freaked me out. So much that I showed my husband my screen and I said to him "I didn't Google that. It's like my phone heard me."
It has happened a few times since then, but never so creepily. Other times could be explained with other Google searches or posts on social media. That one time though, it was eerie.
Edit formatting
1 raquielle 2016-07-16
I first noticed this on my kindle a few years ago. Our toilet was having issues and I had a brief discussion about it with my husband. The next time I picked up my kindle the home screen ad was for a toilet. It gave me the chills.
I've since been very aware of it and see ads that relate to what I was just talking about constantly.
0 Liberum_Sententia 2016-07-16
I was at a bar that had a devil painted on the wall. I took a selfie with it on "social media A" saying "hail satan". At another bar, a friend asked where I saw myself in 10 years, and I answered "machine learning projects".
I log into "social media B", and I am met with two ads. One is for a Satanic group, and the other is for machine-learning. This is bullshit.
I may need to start disconnecting batteries, and only turning on my phone to make calls.
0 wattpuppy 2016-07-16
Yes! This happened to me twice yesterday. I was driving and mentioned a type of animal several times to my wife and kids. A few hours later when I brought up Google there was a search for that animal. I just thought my wife had done it.
1 CelineHagbard 2016-07-16
Maybe more than you'd like to say on an open internet forum, but how did you meet up with him without phones?