Question for the Science guys !
0 2017-06-06 by memorex2017
So earth has an Atmosphere of air and outside this fragile place is the cold Vacuum of space yes ? .My question is what holds the Atmosphere onto the Earth (And if you say GRAVITY you get a C- because well think about how gravity is supposed to work and it would NOT hold Air onto our spinning ball ....) Or please science guys tell me I am wrong ^
33 comments
n/a Rocksolid1111 2017-06-06
Why would gravity not work on air? Have you ever gone to the top of a mountain or higher elevation? You can notice the difference yourself in the air you breathe..
n/a memorex2017 2017-06-06
Gravity attracts objects because of their Mass and Air practically has Zero mass so as I ask please science guys explain ? I cannot believe this only JUST occured to me today !!!
n/a WeAreTheSheeple 2017-06-06
Air is made up off multiple gases. Each gas has a different 'mass' so the gases can lair up on each other.
Helium is a good example. That DOES escape the Earths atmosphere (due to low mass.)
n/a Its-Space_time 2017-06-06
Air is a homogenous mixture...
n/a WeAreTheSheeple 2017-06-06
Air is a mixture of different chemicals. Not just 02 and CO2. They mix down at our level but split as you go up through the atmosphere (lightest up the top.)
n/a scaredshtlessintx 2017-06-06
So if I pop a helium balloon that helium travels off earth?
n/a WeAreTheSheeple 2017-06-06
Yes : (
That's what I've found out over the years. As soon as a balloon is popped, that helium disappears off Earth.
n/a hoeskioeh 2017-06-06
it will rise until it'S density is equal to the air at the height. dunno how high, but pretty far up.
it it there get's agitated enough to reach escape velocity, it might leave earth. yes.
n/a Rocksolid1111 2017-06-06
The gasses in the air have mass.
n/a Iggy0075 2017-06-06
"practically zero mass" so your saying it has some :)
Air pressure at sea level is 14.7psi. This means that if you took a column of air one square inch wide that went all the way up through the atmosphere to space it would way 14.7 lbs.
n/a hoeskioeh 2017-06-06
Mwahahahaha :-D
Classical fish-doesn't-know-what-water-is.
Air is incredibly heavy. A cubic meter of air weighs about 1.3 kgs!
That is a lot.
Besides, gravity effects even photons, which really have zero mass.
n/a AwakenedCattle 2017-06-06
If gravity is strong enough to hold the atmosphere against the earth then why does a helium balloon float away with ease? Gravity magically stopped working when it got to helium?
n/a hoeskioeh 2017-06-06
Buoyancy.
gravity did not suddenly stop for boats, yet they "float" on water.
n/a elcad 2017-06-06
Because it is lighter than the rest of the air. It floats just like a boat in water. Floating is just the denser material forcing the light material up.
n/a AwakenedCattle 2017-06-06
So then at what point does gravity stop working? I thought gravity affected individual photons? But helium is too light?
n/a elcad 2017-06-06
Gravity doesn't stop working. Helium goes up the upper atmosphere. Then forces like the solar wind then come into play.
n/a ryarger 2017-06-06
Gravity is pulling the helium down, the heavier air around the helium is pushing it up. The force of the heavier air is greater than gravity until the helium reaches a certain altitude where the air is thin enough that things are balanced.
n/a Project_Conscious 2017-06-06
Its kind of like holding an air filled object underwater - it will rise up until the buoyancy equalizes
n/a Rayfloyd 2017-06-06
Watch this and tell me your opinion
n/a memorex2017 2017-06-06
My POINT IS the Moon which weighs a shit ton of MASS is held in orbit by the Earths gravity even though it is a quarter million miles away yet air which i'm pretty certain weighs LESS than the moons mass and is FAR CLOSER still gets held here ? something does NOT add up and that is without applying any mathematical formulas ,just common sense :) So carry on with the answers please :)
n/a Rayfloyd 2017-06-06
Just watch the whole videos :P
He goes over what gravity actually is, the rest of the video is very informative since it should be within a couple of months haha
n/a hoeskioeh 2017-06-06
Speed.
The moon has an orbital speed of about ~1km/s.
Get a cloud of air to the same speed (in vacuum, relative to the earth's center of gravity) and it would behave the same. (ok, not the same, the cloud would disperse, but, details).
n/a memorex2017 2017-06-06
their is nothing in a vucuum thats what makes it a vacuum so your point is mute sorry :(
n/a memorex2017 2017-06-06
I like it :) more people should open their minds and ask more questions instead of being herded through their lives like brainless sheep ,but I'm over half a century old and the herd grows daily so I guess the planet is doomed to stupidity regardless of how many common sense videos there are out there ;)
n/a Rayfloyd 2017-06-06
You're right about the herd getting bigger but I believe we can beat it...
It's a shame his videos aren't more popular, he always raises the good questions and is pretty informative
n/a memorex2017 2017-06-06
The amount of times I explain something to someone that is 100% Logical and they say "Oh that's weird" scares me to death ,even when you present someone with something that's 100% genuine by common sense reason and they still don't believe it terrifies me , I guess that's why I made the choice to never have kids because this shit is getting worse by the day and I see no sign of it getting better :(
n/a Rayfloyd 2017-06-06
Hahahaha I hear ya and agree very much
But I have hope, Trump is playing its role so far, he's having trouble but I think he can beat the deep state
He's been smug as all hell ever since his trip. Disrespected a bunch of peeps there, and the media completely dropping the russia story and even doing some not so flattering pieces on Clinton it looks promising
n/a VenomousVoice 2017-06-06
So weird! I was just thinking about vacuums and Earth's atmosphere last night. Had exact same question. I figured it's gravity that holds it all together. But super strange that we're thinking the same thoughts at the same time...
n/a soonerchad 2017-06-06
Ringed Mongoose to base, Ringed Mongoose to base; we got one that can see. Permission to shill????
n/a sgtpinback 2017-06-06
the weight of the air around earth is about equivalent to 12 feet of concrete...gravity pulls it down. it is also a shield against radiation. but also the earths gravity holds the moon in orbit, and that is about 250000 miles away..so an atom of air at 250000 miles has to have a speed greater than the moon to get away from earth.
n/a ConvertsToMetric 2017-06-06
Mouseover or click to view the metric conversion for this comment
n/a Vechthaan 2017-06-06
The scientific explanation is that a vacuum by itself doesn't create a force. It's the atmosphere (air particles) that want to push themselves into the vacuum, due to the law of equilibrium. (Gasses of different pressure that aren't seperated will even out in pressure)
The fact still remains that at the edge of space, despite there being nearly no air pressure, there's still no physical boundry holding the air in. So even with the official explanation that "a vacuum doesn't suck", it still doesn't make sense.
If there is no physical boundry seperating space from atmosphere, what's preventing the air from flowing into space, even if there is nihil* pressure, it's **still more than 0 pressure (space).
And the anwser to that is magical gravity. And people say flat earthers are the ones grasping at straws lel.
n/a WadeWilsonforPope 2017-06-06
Where is the force coming from to pull the air into space?
Gravity is the acceptable answer. It doesnt just stop, it gets thinner and thinner.
n/a ToddWhiskey 2017-06-06
The Earth's magnetic field.
n/a FreeDennisReynolds 2017-06-06
My post history has flat Earth for beginners links. It's true, Earth isn't a spinning ball flying 30km/sec in a random direction, and learning that won't only change everything for you but could end the NWO. The stars look like they spin around a dome, you feel no movement, there's no curve up on an airplane but you see ships go over the curve at ground level? You see Mercury and Venus in the middle of the night, hm? Neil Degrass Tyson is an actor, living a lie